« If The Democrats Lose, They Still Win | Main | Over the Hump and Over the Cliff »

March 20, 2010

Obama: The Great Divider

B. Daniel Blatt at GayPatriot has such a brilliant insight I'll steal both the title of his post and the theme (while giving credit, of course!).

For years the left complained that George W. Bush was "the great divider, not uniter." The charge did have a certain amount of merit, in that for a time the war in Iraq bitterly divided the nation. Never mind, of course, that most Democrats voted for the war. But it is true that for various reasons, most of them dishonest, I think, they turned against it.

But Obama has divided America like no president for the past century. His proposals, from the "stimulus" to this insane health care bill have been met with almost unanimous opposition from Republicans. He has made no meaningful attempt to reach out to the right and incorporate any of our ideas.

Instead, Obama has shown himself the most vain, arrogant, narcissistic president since.... I don't know, Teddy Roosevelt? No, Obama even beats him. With large congressional majorities he proclaimed "we won" and that was that.

This is not how public policy should be enacted.

As much as I'd like all pieces of legislation to toe the conservative line one hundred percent, I know that's not possible (this is also what separates me from the purists on the right). As a practical matter, all legislation will take some bipartisanship to enact, which is why the Democrats are having such trouble. And as a policy standpoint, you want at least some buy-in from at least some people on the other side of the isle.

Consider that all of the major pieces of legislation over the past 100 years; Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, the 1964 Civil Rights Act, were passed with mostly bipartisan majorities. Not this one. This shows an astounding ignorance or contempt of history by this president and his minions in congress, and they will pay a steep price at the polls this November if they enact it.

In a much quoted column in the Wall Street Journal, , Peggy Noonan nails it

And so it ends, with a health-care vote expected this weekend. I wonder at what point the administration will realize it wasn't worth it--worth the discord, worth the diminution in popularity and prestige, worth the deepening of the great divide. What has been lost is so vivid, what has been gained so amorphous, blurry and likely illusory. Memo to future presidents: Never stake your entire survival on the painful passing of a bad bill. Never take the country down the road to Demon Pass.

("demon pass" being a reference to how "deem and pass" sounds).

Whether this bill passes or not, Obama will have divided this nation like nothing I've ever seen. We've had temporary divides, like the impeachment of President Clinton, but that was a special situation. With Obama its over policy, and a lot of them. And it just seems to get worse and worse as time goes by. Whatever will he do if the Republicans make strong gains in November, perhaps even taking back one or both houses of congress?

Note on Peggy Noonan because this is bound to come up

Yes yes, fellow conservatives, I know that Noonan was once a sort-of supporter of Obama. But isn't that just the point?

If the normally clear-thinking Peggy Noonan was fooled but now smells the coffee, imagine how many others are also having second thoughts? A poll I saw after the last election showed that 20 percent of self-identified conservatives voted for Obama. We've certainly got them back. Many in the middle voted for him. We can get them back. All on the left voted for him, but are now disappointed. They may not vote for anyone in 2012 and will certainly not campaign as hard and contribute as much money. All of this presents us with an opportunity. Rather than beat up on people like Noonan, let's forgive them and move on.

Posted by Tom at March 20, 2010 9:30 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.theredhunter.com/mt/refer.cgi/1550

Comments

It certainly is odd to look back and remember that Obama beat Clinton in the primaries mainly by promising that he was a unifying figure who would transcend the culture wars and usher in an age of bipartisanship....

Posted by: Mylne Karimov at March 21, 2010 12:44 AM

Tom, I understand this is a crucial weekend for that health "care" bill. But with regards to that much vaunted "wait till November" I'm not holding my breath.

Because... legislation, no matter how insane or how unnecessary, has a tendency to REMAIN IN PLACE, even if those responsible for it disappear from the stage.

I've seen it so many times here in Europe. Yes, the hardcore socialists have in many countries been relegated to the wings. But the stuff they are responsible for - gay marriage, gay adoption, abortion legislation - stays in effect.

That is why it is necessary to beat Obama not in November, but NOW. NOW.

Sheesh, dunno how Americans should do it, but the passing of this bill has to be prevented... NOW.

Winning House and Senate back in Nov matters only half, or even less, if the bill passes.

Posted by: Outlaw Mike at March 21, 2010 7:00 PM

You are so right, Mike. Once these things are enacted they're almost impossible to completely undo. Thanks for stopping by.

Posted by: Tom the Redhunter at March 21, 2010 9:04 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)